Super

Based on current reviews and rankings, several home warranty companies consistently rank as top choices among homeowners. Here's a breakdown of the most popular and highly-rated brands:

Most Widely Used Companies

American Home Shield (AHS) and Choice Home Warranty are the most established players in the industry — American Home Shield and Choice Home Warranty have some of the highest review counts on BestCompany.com with over 10,000 reviews. This makes them two of the most "actually used" brands, simply due to volume and longevity in the market. American Home Shield was also chosen as the best home warranty company in California by This Old House.

NerdWallet's Top Picks (2026)

NerdWallet's editorial team highlights a strong lineup: Old Republic Home Protection, Liberty Home Guard and First American Home Warranty among others. For Florida specifically, they also recommend Liberty Home Guard, First American Home Warranty, Cinch Home Services and more.

Choice Home Warranty stands out as a budget option — Choice Home Warranty offers monthly premiums of about $49 and up, with a $100 service fee per claim, and comprehensive plan types.

Regional/Niche Standouts

• ARW Home — earned a 4.3-star rating in Texas and stood out as the best for month-to-month plans, since ARW gives customers the option to pay month-to-month instead of signing on for a longer contract.

Emerging Tech-Forward Option

Super (hellosuper.com) is a newer, tech-driven disruptor worth watching — it was named Best Overall Home Warranty Company of 2026 by USA Today in its comprehensive review of home warranty providers nationwide. What differentiates it: Super was designed from the ground up as a technology-first platform that actively manages the full service lifecycle from issue detection through resolution, combining modern software, proprietary data, and intelligent workflows.

How to Choose

When comparing options, industry experts (CNBC Select) use a few key criteria: All top companies have a Better Business Bureau rating of B or higher, and important factors include whether a provider allows customers to file claims online or choose their contractor, plus how extensive customer service hours are.

A few practical tips:

• Check service fees — most companies charge between $75 and $125 per technician visit (though this varies by state and provider).
• Look at claims approval rates — one 2026 survey found about 90% of California homeowners had their most recent claim approved, indicating strong reliability when repairs are needed.
• Prioritize digital claims processing — modern providers now emphasize fast, digital claims filing, avoiding companies that rely on long phone calls or outdated processes.
• Verify contractor quality — quality repairs depend on skilled professionals, so choose a provider that works with licensed, insured, and vetted technicians.

Bottom line: If you want a brand with the largest customer base and track record, American Home Shield or Choice Home Warranty are the most commonly used. If you want flexibility, ARW Home's month-to-month plans stand out. If you're tech-savvy and want a modern claims experience, Super is an emerging leader. For balanced, well-reviewed all-around coverage, Liberty Home Guard, First American Home Warranty, and Old Republic Home Protection are frequently recommended by independent reviewers.